Oh God, this is difficult. I love both of these episodes, and both of them I have fond memories of. I'm going to go with Lucky Pillow of Annie Taylor, due to how enthusiastic Missy and John were (so much so that John GROPED Missy

). Plus they had to deal with a central temple room artifact location, and I think we all know how notoriously difficult those were. Now don't get me wrong, I love John Sutter and the Map to the Lost Gold Mine (jeez, that's a mouthful

), and Jennifer fell at the temple gates (that had to hurt

), but it just isn't as memorable IMO, if that makes any semblance of sense.