This was touched upon in the Name that Picture thread when PPF posted a picture of the Blue Barracudas from John Henry's Lost Hammer who bore a striking resemblance to Damian and Jennifer from the Map to the Lost Gold Mine (of which I agree). It was suggested to move the discussion to its' own thread, so here it is.
To get the ball rolling, I'm pretty sure that the Blue Barracudas who got replaced by the Silver Snakes (after they had gotten wrongly sent back at the moat) at the steps in the Applewood Amulet of Emiliano Zapata later came back as the Purple Parrots in the Priceless Portrait of the Polynesian Girl. Here's a side-by-side comparison:
Players | Original Episode | Original Team | Original Outcome | Second Episode | Second Team | Second Outcome |
Chris & Janet | The Applewood Amulet of Emiliano Zapata | Blue Barracudas | Replaced by Silver Snakes at Steps | The Priceless Portrait of the Polynesian Girl | Purple Parrots | Lost Temple Games |
Jim & Kristen | The Imperial Purple Robe of Empress Theodora | Silver Snakes | Lost at Steps | The Priceless Portrait of the Polynesian Girl | Silver Snakes | Ran out of time in Temple, but reached artifact |
Hallie & Jared | The Mystical Spellbook of the Imperial Wizard | Orange Iguanas | Lost at Moat | The Useless Map of the Chibcha Chieftain | Orange Iguanas | Lost in temple due to triple capture |
Christine & Jeremy | The Smashed Printing Plate of Frederick Douglass | Green Monkeys | Lost at Moat | The Golden Spider Web of Robert the Bruce | Green Monkeys | Lost in temple due to triple capture |
Jennifer | The Mysterious Manuscript of Mary Shelley | Orange Iguanas | Lost at Moat | The Melted Head of Madame Tussaud | Orange Iguanas (With different partner) | Ran out of time in Temple |
Name Unknown | The Mysterious Manuscript of Mary Shelley | Orange Iguanas | Lost at Moat | The Lost Taj Mahal Turban of Aurangzeb | Orange Iguanas (With different partner) | Lost at Steps |
Josh & Sarah | Galileo's Cannonball | Red Jaguars | Lost at Moat | Wild Bill Hickok and the Dead Man's Hand | Orange Iguanas | Ran out of time in Temple |
Names Unknown | Galileo's Cannonball | Purple Parrots | Lost at Moat | Wild Bill Hickok and the Dead Man's Hand | Purple Parrots | Lost at Moat (again) |
Damian & Jennifer | John Henry's Lost Hammer | Blue Barracudas | Lost at Moat | John Sutter and the Map to the Lost Gold Mine | Blue Barracudas | Won Grand Prize! |
Names unknown | John Henry's Lost Hammer | Green Monkeys | Disqualified at Moat | John Sutter and the Map to the Lost Gold Mine | Green Monkeys | Lost at Moat |
Names Unknown | The Golden Cricket Cage of Khan | Green Monkeys | Lost at Moat | John Sutter and the Map to the Lost Gold Mine | Red Jaguars | Lost at Steps |
Names Unknown | The Golden Cricket Cage of Khan | Orange Iguanas | Lost at Moat | John Sutter and the Map to the Lost Gold Mine | Orange Iguanas | Lost at Moat (again) |
Names Unknown | Elizabeth I's Golden Ship | Blue Barracudas | Lost at Moat | John Sutter and the Map to the Lost Gold Mine | Purple Parrots | Lost at Steps |
Brook & Perry | Elizabeth I's Golden Ship | Green Monkeys | Lost at Moat | John Sutter and the Map to the Lost Gold Mine | Silver Snakes | Lost Temple Games |
Names Unknown | The Star of Sultan Saladin | Purple Parrots | Lost at Moat | The Pendant of Kamehameha | Green Monkeys | Lost at Moat (again) |
Names Unknown | The Star of Sultan Saladin | Orange Iguanas | Lost at Moat | The Pendant of Kamehameha | Orange Iguanas | Lost at Steps |
Names Unknown | The Keys to the Alhambra | Purple Parrots | Lost at Moat | The Pendant of Kamehameha | Purple Parrots | Lost at Steps |
Maria & Mike | The Keys to the Alhambra | Green Monkeys | Lost at Moat | The Pendant of Kamehameha | Red Jaguars | Lost Temple Games |
Robbie & Tina | The Helmet of Genghis Khan | Purple Parrots | Lost at Moat | The Pendant of Kamehameha | Silver Snakes | Lost in Temple due to triple capture |
Names Unknown | The Helmet of Genghis Khan | Orange Iguanas | Lost at Moat | The Pendant of Kamehameha | Blue Barracudas | Lost at Moat (again) |
Names Unknown | The Lost Log Books of Magellan | Red Jaguars | Lost at Moat | The Lucky Pig of Amelia Earhart | Red Jaguars | Lost at Steps |
Annie & Brad | The Lost Logbooks of Magellan | Purple Parrots | Lost at Moat | The Lucky Pig of Amelia Earhart | Purple Parrots | Lost Temple Games |
Scott & Kristen | The Mox-a-kins of Geronimo | Red Jaguars | Lost at Moat | The Lucky Pig of Amelia Earhart | Blue Barracudas | Ran out of time in Temple |
Names Unknown | The Mox-a-kins of Geronimo | Orange Iguanas | Lost at Moat | The Lucky Pig of Amelia Earhart | Orange Iguanas | Lost at Moat (again)
|
Names Unknown | Henry VIII's Great Seal | Orange Iguanas | Lost at Moat | The Lucky Pig of Amelia Earhart | Green Monkeys | Lost at Moat (again) |
Names Unknown | Henry VIII's Great Seal | Purple Parrots | Lost at Moat | The Lucky Pig of Amelia Earhart | Silver Snakes | Lost at Steps |
Roberto & Katie | Ponce de Leon and the Lost Fountain of Youth | Orange Iguanas | Lost at Moat | The Paintbrush of Leonardo da Vinci | Orange Iguanas | Ran out of time in Temple |
Names Unknown | Ponce de Leon and the Lost Fountain of Youth | Silver Snakes | Lost at Moat | The Paintbrush of Leonardo Da Vinci | Silver Snakes | Lost at Moat (again)
|
Names Unknown | Blackbeard's Treasure Map | Purple Parrots | Lost at Moat | The Paintbrush of Leonardo Da Vinci | Purple Parrots | Lost at Moat (again) |
Names Unknown | Blackbeard's Treasure Map | Green Monkeys | Lost at Moat | The Paintbrush of Leonardo Da Vinci | Green Monkeys | Lost at Steps |
Ansie & Chris | The Treasure Map of Jean Lafitte | Silver Snakes | Lost at Moat | The Paintbrush of Leonardo Da Vinci | Blue Barracudas | Lost Temple Games |
Names Unknown | The Oracle Bowl of Delphi | Red Jaguars | Lost at Moat | The Paintbrush of Leonardo Da Vinci | Red Jaguars | Lost at Steps |
Names Unknown | The Stolen Arm of Shiva | Purple Parrots | Lost at Moat | The Helmet of Joan of Arc | Silver Snakes | Lost at Moat (again) |
Eddie & Mandy | The Stolen Arm of Shiva | Green Monkeys | Lost at Moat | The Helmet of Joan of Arc | Red Jaguars | Ran out of time in Temple |
Brian & Amanda | The Golden Chains of Zenobia | Blue Barracudas | Lost at Moat | The Helmet of Joan of Arc | Blue Barracudas | Lost Temple Games |
Names Unknown | The Golden Chains of Zenobia | Green Monkeys | Lost at Moat | The Helmet of Joan of Arc | Green Monkeys | Lost at Steps |
Names Unknown | The Belly Button of Buddha | Orange Iguanas | Lost at Moat | The Helmet of Joan of Arc | Orange Iguanas | Lost at Steps |
Names Unknown | The Belly Button of Buddha | Purple Parrots | Lost at Moat | The Helmet of Joan of Arc | Purple Parrots | Lost at Moat (again)
|
Names Unknown | The Mask of Shaka Zulu | Purple Parrots | Lost at Moat | Alexander and the Gordian Knot | Red Jaguars | Lost at Moat (again) |
Names Unknown | The Mask of Shaka Zulu | Blue Barracudas | Lost at Moat | Alexander and the Gordian Knot | Blue Barracudas | Lost at Steps |
Tim & Retina | The Medal of Sir Edmund Hillary | Orange Iguanas | Lost at Moat | Alexander and the Gordian Knot | Orange Iguanas | Ran out of time in Temple |
Names Unknown | The Medal of Sir Edmund Hillary | Purple Parrots | Lost at Moat | Alexander and the Gordian Knot | Purple Parrots | Lost at Moat (again) |
Names Unknown | The Golden Jaguar of Atahualpa | Green Monkeys | Lost at Moat | Alexander and the Gordian Knot | Green Monkeys | Lost at Steps |
Bo & Molly | The Golden Jaguar of Atahualpa | Silver Snakes | Lost at Moat | Alexander and the Gordian Knot | Silver Snakes | Lost Temple Games |
Names Unknown | The Dragon Lady and the Blue Pearl | Green Monkeys | Lost at Moat |  | Red Jaguars | Lost at Steps |
Dustin & Nicole | The Dragon Lady and the Blue Pearl | Purple Parrots | Lost at Moat |  | Purple Parrots | Lost Temple Games |
Names Unknown | King Tut's Cobra Staff | Green Monkeys | Lost at Moat |  | Green Monkeys | Lost at Moat (again) |
Names Unknown | King Tut's Cobra Staff | Orange Iguanas | Lost at Moat |  | Orange Iguanas | Lost at Moat (again) |
Names Unknown | The Codebook of Mata Hari | Green Monkeys | Lost at Moat |  | Blue Barracudas | Lost at Steps |
Jeremy & Erica | The Codebook of Mata Hari | Orange Iguanas | Lost at Moat |  | Silver Snakes | Won Grand Prize! |
Katherine & Ron | The Collar of Davy Crockett | Purple Parrots | Lost at Moat | The Treasure of Anne Bonny | Red Jaguars | Ran out of time in Temple, but reached artifact |
Names Unknown | The Collar of Davy Crockett | Orange Iguanas | Lost at Moat | The Treasure of Anne Bonny | Orange Iguanas | Lost at Moat (again) |
Names Unknown | Lawrence of Arabia's Headdress | Blue Barracudas | Lost at Moat | The Treasure of Anne Bonny | Blue Barracudas | Lost at Steps |
Names Unknown | Lawrence of Arabia's Headdress | Purple Parrots | Lost at Moat | The Treasure of Anne Bonny | Purple Parrots | Lost at Steps |
Joanna & Nate | The Snake Bracelet of Cleopatra | Red Jaguars | Lost at Moat | The Treasure of Anne Bonny | Green Monkeys | Lost Temple Games |
Names Unknown | The Snake Bracelet of Cleopatra | Blue Barracudas | Lost at Moat | The Treasure of Anne Bonny | Silver Snakes | Lost at Moat (again) |