Yeah, I remember some people comparing Billy the Kid to "

". I definitely don't think Billy the Kid should rank low on the totem pole like Silk Ladder and Shaka Zulu. I don't think the producers gave Tony and Kelly a win on a silver platter either like they did for the last production day of the show. It was just luck of the draw that they ended up with a more simpler layout. Plus, it always felt like the Shrine temple runs had the simpler paths anyways. Davy Crockett, Roland,

, Dr. Livingstone, Bandit Queen, and Egyptian Queen were all similar paths to Billy the Kid. Even runs like Icarus and Poseidon had very simple paths too where the contestants reached the artifact with a lot of time.
As for the win itself, I think it deserves more credit that it already gets. A win to me is not always about the layout. This run is very memorable for the fact it was the very first Purple Parrot win and how strong Kelly and Tony were pre-temple rounds. And I don't think Tony's exit was that bad either. He could've been like Ron, Tara, and Jason who blew their runs by taking inefficient routes. The only real flaw to me was Tony detouring to the bottom of the Ledges. But he pulled it off in the end, and even with some time on the clock. I have no problems with this win or run at all. It's probably the Purple Parrots biggest shining moment next to Freydis.
Also, it always made me wonder if the producers kept track of "temple statistics"? Like did they realize the Purple Parrots never had a victory before Billy the Kid? And how certain runs like bottom of the central shaft artifacts were never successful? This is pretty interesting to think about. IIRC, in Zac's interview, the producers told him that he held the record for the fastest temple exit on the show. So it does make me wonder if the producers knew that the Purple Parrots were winless before Billy the Kid?