Here's an update. Don't feel like including 0's next to everyone right now. Just assume no number means 0 strikes. Kelly has a number next to her name because she has 2 strikes.
Paula (The Silver Horseshoe of Butch Cassidy)
Kendra (The Golden Stallion of Ali Baba)
Amber (The Silver Cannonball of Grandy Nanny)
Olivia-Emma (The Applewood Amulet of Emiliano Zapata)
Leah (The Bone Necklace of the Blackfeet Chief)
Tabitha (The Diary of Dr. Livingstone)
Michelle (The Electrified Key of Benjamin Franklin)
Ashley (The Imperial Purple Robe of Empress Theodora)
Whitney (The Lost Love Letter of Captain John Smith)
Missy (The Lucky Pillow of Annie Taylor)
Angela (The Mush Pot Hat of Johnny Appleseed)
Heather (The Stone Head of the Evil King)
Ryann (The Walking Stick of Harriet Tubman)
Renee (The Crown of Queen Nzinga)
Monica (The Ivory Elephant of Scheherazade)
Kelly (The Jeweled Necklace of Montezuma) (2)
Marie (The Lost Lion Tail of Little John)
Danielle (The Mask of the Man in the Iron Mask)
Emily (The Missing Eye of David)
Jessica (The Plumed Headdress of Cosa Rara)
Gracelyn (The Sacred Ring of Sultan Suleiman)
Jenelle (The Shriveled Hand of Efoua)
Carly (The Two-Cornered Hat of Napoléon)
Rachelle "Shelly" (The Golden Goblet of Attila the Hun)
Chandra (The Leopard-Skin Cloak of Annie Oakley)
Jessie (The Silk Sash of Mùlán)
Kelly (The Snakeskin Boots of Billy the Kid)
Ashlie (The Bonnet of Dolley Madison)
Ashley (The Golden Earring of Henry Morgan)
Aqila (The Golden Pepperoni of Catherine de' Medici)
Elizabeth (The Levitating Dog Leash of Nostradamus)
Tarrah (The Milk Bucket of Freydís)
Kristen (The Priceless Portrait of the Polynesian Girl)
James (The Secret Battle Plan of Nathan Hale)
C.J. (The Golden Stallion of Ali Baba)
Jonathan (The Silver Cannonball of Grandy Nanny)
Robert (The Applewood Amulet of Emiliano Zapata)
Brandon (The Bone Necklace of the Blackfeet Chief)
Josh (The Cracked Crown of the Spanish King)
Brett (The Diary of Dr. Livingstone)
Peter (The Electrified Key of Benjamin Franklin)
Joshua (The Imperial Purple Robe of Empress Theodora)
Derrick Kujak (The Lost Love Letter of Captain John Smith)
Ty (The Lucky Medallion of Atocha)
Chris (The Mush Pot Hat of Johnny Appleseed)
Chris (The Walking Stick of Harriet Tubman)
Benjamin (The Crown of Queen Nzinga)
Joel (The Enormous Iron Nose Ring of Babe)
Brad (The Ivory Elephant of Scheherazade)
Kevin (The Jeweled Necklace of Montezuma)
Justin (The Mask of the Man in the Iron Mask)
Michael (The Missing Eye of David)
Justin (The Plumed Headdress of Cosa Rara)
Brian (The Sacred Ring of Sultan Suleiman)
Bobby (The Shriveled Hand of Efoua)
Brian (The Two-Cornered Hat of Napoléon)
Shane (The Very Tall Turban of Ahmed Baba)
Nick (The Leopard-Skin Cloak of Annie Oakley)
Steven (The Silk Sash of Mùlán)
Tony (The Snakeskin Boots of Billy the Kid)
Matt (The Bonnet of Dolley Madison)
Jason (The Broken Wing of Icarus)
Shem (The Golden Earring of Henry Morgan)
Chris (The Golden Pepperoni of Catherine de' Medici)
Jason (The Levitating Dog Leash of Nostradamus)
Nick (The Missing Weather Maps of Charles Lindbergh)
Jim (The Priceless Portrait of the Polynesian Girl)