Wow, Leah could totally fit this description even though that's not the name I was quite looking for. I will accept that answer though since it fits perfectly.

- This name was used by three contestants, one that appeared in each season.
- Two of the contestants that shared this name got a loss in the temple, while the other got a win.
- One of the contestants that shared this name was the first one to complete a feat that three previous runs failed to do.
I fixed the last clue though to make it less ambiguous. But THK can make one if he likes since he technically found an answer that fits.
