Man, this thread and its brother shouldn't have taken more than a year. Better keep that in mind in case somebody decides to make another one of these...

Jennifer: +5
Tarrah: -5
Jennifer (The Belly Button of Buddha) 655
Tarrah (The Milk Bucket of Freyd?s) 6
#20: Shannon (The Collar of Davy Crockett)
#19: Katherine "Fred" (The Treasure of Anne Bonny)
#18: Elizabeth Humphries (The Levitating Dog Leash of Nostradamus)
#17: Candace (Lawrence of Arabia's Headdress)
#16: Randy (The Metal Beard of the Egyptian Queen)
#15: Carly (The Two-Cornered Hat of Napol?on)
#14: Tiffani (The Much-Heralded Helmet of Sir Gawain)
#13: Amanda (The Mussel Shell Armor of Apanuugpak)
#12: Olivia-Emma Juliana (The Applewood Amulet of Emiliano Zapata)
#11: Kelley (The Snakeskin Boots of Billy the Kid)
#10: Jennifer (The Dragon Lady and the Blue Pearl)
#9: Yakerra (The Ivory Hunting Horn of Roland)
#8: Andrea (The Lion-Headed Bracelet of Chandragupta)
#7: Annie (The Ruby Earring of bin-Zibab)
#6: Jessica (The Lost Hornpipe of the Pirate Captain)
#5: Missy (The Lucky Pillow of Annie Taylor)
#4: Kristin (The Jewel-Encrusted Egg of Catherine the Great)
#3: Jennifer (John Sutter and the Map to the Lost Gold Mine)