Ok, so after much debate, I voted for the Discarded Seal. The two players in this episode were really good, but they just had rotten luck with the temple guards. They had absolutely no chance of winning, and they didn't even have to enter all the rooms. Also, the item was not in the center room. You know something's wrong when the toughest layout doesn't require a team to get the item from the center room.
I think Hans Holbein was doable if the girl just moved faster and didn't have to climb out of the Pit of the Pendulum. Keith was really fast. I'm not sure if the Shrine-Bog door opened, but if it did, he could've gone that way instead of the Password. Also, Keith trying the third suit in the Ancient Warriors when the door was already open was unnecessary. Basically, the players in this run weren't near as perfect as the players from the Discarded Seal. If they were, then my vote might have been different.