Well, Emily was officially eliminated with 1:05 left, but would've entered the Dark Forest with ~57sec left .
Also, Michael took 30sec to complete Medusa's Lair out of the 73sec he was in the temple. (from start to time of capture in the Laser Light Room)
Then Emily took 29sec getting to where Michael left off and completed the Laser Light Room in 6sec (from the time her feet hit the floor to the time she first contacted the exit door)
So we take the 1:55 elapsed time at the time of third capture, subtract the 5sec Michael took to enter the Crypt, subtract the 29sec from Emily's unimpeded run to the Laser Light room, then add the 8sec that Emily took to get through the Swamp, and we get a total in-room completion time of 1:29. we then divide that time by 6 to get an average time for each room completion of 14.83sec.
So, In my opinion, if either the Forest/Shrine or Shaft/Shrine doors opened for Emily, she would've won. If she had to ride the elevator up and complete the Lightning Ball room, it would've been close.
What if Gabby found the other half of her pendant before entering the Room of the Golden Idols?