29
« on: December 30, 2019, 08:37:55 PM »
“Murder is an inherently evil act, no matter what the circumstances, no matter how convincing the rationalizations.”
Bentley Little (The Ignored)
Episode 5; Time to Change the Rules
Last time on Murder in Small Town X;
The Killer struck again, eliminating a suspect.
Mitchell-“Who’s dead?”
Jack-“....Georgina....”
Georgina-“AHHHH!”
FLASH! BANG!
A the crime scene, the investigators found a surprise.
Robbin Evans slipped in the blood by the sink and landed with a thud.
And Rachel Neary still wouldn’t budge.
Rachel-“Leave or I will call security! Your choice!”
Jennifer Harris gave some insight into the check the investigators found.
Jennifer-“Matthew found out about me sleeping with a student.”
Chrissy-“How did Matthew find out?”
Jennifer-“Some of us have nephews who brag to their uncles.”
And Diane just wanted everything back to normal.
Diane-“Like I said, I know him better than anyone else. He was my whole world since we first started dating. I just wish he would change his ways.”
At HQ, the group cleared Cooper Davis as a suspect by way of the Killer Question. Then in the Killer’s Game, Deanna was once again placed into the it by way of the group vote, and Harrison shocked the group by picking Doug after his partner, Mitchell, caught Doug, Kristen, and Chrissy’s alliance trying to run the house.
In the end, Deanna survived the Woods at Harper Park to find the clue, while the curtain fell on Doug at the Playhouse Theatre and he was eliminated from the game.
Now only 10 Suspects and 6 Investigators Remain.
It's 3:19 in the morning. Everyone is sound asleep in their beds in the small town. At HQ, it was no different. The group slept quietly, aside from Deanna, who was tossing and turning in her sleep, possibly having a bad dream from her second trip out to find the clue. But while she had her nightmare of the Killer, the real Killer was about to start a real life nightmare in the city.
Their van slowly pulled up to a house. Just like last time, the headlights were off on the van to keep them as stealth like as possible. They turned on their infrared camera and grabbed the unused body bag from the next to the one that was currently preoccupied.
Slowly, on foot, the green glow approached the house. They arrived at the back door and realized that they left their crowbar at Georgina's house. Without that or their lock picks, they should of just left. They didn't. They want this kill.
Thinking on their feet, they grabbed a rock and broke a panel of glass from the back door. Quickly they reached in and unlocked the door and entered the house. Without anytime to waste, they hid in a corner of the room as footsteps came closer and closer.
Woman-"What in the world was that?"
The Killer watched the lady arrived in her slippers and a robe. She surveyed the scene and looked at the ground where the former window was now laying in pieces.
Women-"What the hell happened?"
The lady walked back into the other room, completely oblivious to the intruder in her house. She entered into the other room and grabbed a phone. As soon as the Killer realized she was calling the police, they acted fast. The green haze of inferred rushed forward at the lady. She turned around to a surprise.
Woman-"Hello. I.... AHHHHHH!"
FLASH! BANG!
***
In the quiet town of Sunrise Ridge, a Killer is on the loose. A reward has been offered to 10 ordinary people;
Deanna
Benjamin
Chrissy
Frank
Stacey
Harrison
Kristen
Doug
Heidi
Mitchell
They have been sent to Sunrise Ridge to play the Killer's twister game. Now, they must enter the mind of a Killer and solve the mystery, or else they will be eliminated, one by one.
***
Per the usual, at roughly 8:00 AM, Spencer and Tiffany dropped off breakfast for the investigators. The remaining 6 enjoyed their meal, while Deanna went straight to the coffee again.
Deanna-"I hate the Killer's Game. Last night's was the creepiest yet. I kinda just wanna stand outside later tonight and just let the Killer get me cause I don't know if I'll be able to do it again."
The group was just about to take their food and leave when Gary came in. He had an expression of despair mixed with chaos on his face, with a dash of sleepiness thrown in as well.
Gary-"Everybody. 5 minutes. Briefing Room."
Everyone looked at him like a ghost just walked in.
Benjamin-"When Gary busted in like that, it was a shock. We've never seen him like that before. Something must of happened."
Chrissy-"I got a bad feeling, with the way Gary came flying in, that our easy morning has ended early."
The group grabbed their plates and made their way to the Briefing Room. Gary was found with his face in his hands as he also let out a deep sighing yawn. Once the last of the group made it in, he addressed them.
Gary-"Alright, I got a call from Jack Faye a little while ago. The Killer has struck again."
The group gasped at the info.
Mitchell-"Once again the Killer acts in the middle of the night. We need to catch this person soon."
Gary-"Now, it sadly comes as 'Good News, Bad News' for us. Obviously, bad news is someone is dead. However, we can now clear a suspect because of it."
The group looked at each other as they wondered who the Killer cleared for them. Their question was answered very quickly as Gary took his red sharpie and walked over to his suspect bored. He reached up and threw a big red X over the face of the deceased suspect. The group looked in awe at who it was.
It was Diane Pearlman. Thanks to the Killer, the now deceased beautician was cleared of being the bad guy.
Chrissy-"Diane is dead!?"
Gary-"I'm afraid so. She called the police department around 3:25 and, well, I have the audio from the call."
He then held up a Flash Drive and placed it into the USB port on the computer. After a few clicks, the TV above the table showed the official Seal of the Sunrise Ridge Police Department. A play button sat directly on top of the logo.
Gary-"Now, just like the Killer's first video they sent us, I've already listen to this, and it sounds as bad as the video was. I'm sorry in advance if it's hard for you, too."
With that warning, Gary moved the cursor over the play button and clicked it.
Jack-"Sunrise Ridge Police Department, how can I help you?"
Diane-"Hello, I.... AHHHHH!"
What sounded like a struggle then took place, followed by the panicked screams of Diane.
Diane-"AHHHH!!!! GET AWAY FROM ME!!!!!"
Jack-"Hello?! Is everything OK?"
Diane-"HHHHEEEEELLLLLPPPP!!!"
BANG!
Some of the investigators jumped when the bang was heard. After what seemed like an eternity, the ironic dead silence was finally broken.
Jack-"Hello? HELLO!?"
He dropped the phone in his rush to get to his radio.
Jack-"I need a call traced! Another homicide!"
The audio ended.
Kristen-"The Killer claimed another victim. This is insane. They've broken in here, they've broken into the homes of the victims. I don't know where it's gonna go next."
Gary-"Now, police arrived to Diane's house and found no body, but the amount of blood suggest that she is no longer with us. Now, on to other items. Last night, Deanna again returned with the Killer Clue. What did you find out there?"
Deanna-"I was dropped off right at the spot Ashley was found. I walked over to a note that told me to follow the caution tape that was tied to the trees to the clue. I followed it and it brought me deep into the woods. I arrived at a flare where the clue was."
Gary-"I'm very proud of you. This is what the Killer left us. A Massachusetts license plate."
He held it up for the group to see.
Gary-"I've already talked to Jack Faye about it, and he ran the plate and found out it was registered to a truck that once belonged to Matthew Bundy."
The 6 investigators all started writing and whispering to each other over the major clue.
Gary-"Now, let's get to the investigation. As we know, Deanna returned again last night, but unfortunately Doug did not. I'm going to play Doug's Last Will and Testament and see who he named as the next Lead Investigator."
Gary clicked open a file on the computer, and a video with Doug appeared before the group on the TV over head. Just as Gary hit play, like with the others, he walked away to grab the name plate in front of Doug's desk and placed it on his board along with Heidi, Frank, and Stacey's names in his own makeshift "In Memory" mural.
Doug-"I can't believe I have to make this. I don't blame Harrison, but I'm also not happy with him. As for who I pick for Lead Investigator, it's down between 2 people that I want to have it."
He then reaches into his pocket and pulls out a quarter and flips it.
Doug-"My choice is Chrissy. I believe her and Kristen can get to the end. They're both really good investigators and I think they can solve it."
Gary-"Chrissy, congratulations! You are the Lead Investigator."
Chrissy grabbed her stuff from her desk and made her way to the front of the room
Chrissy-"I have a good and bad feeling about being in this position today. After last night, I know Kristen and I are targets now."
Gary-"So today, the 2 tracks are as follows; Track 1, I am sending you to Diane's house. We found a casing at the last crime scene, let's see if we can find another here and prove that a gun is being used. Track 2, you are going to the Town Hall. I want you to look into this Tracey Johnson girl and find anything and everything you can about her. Chrissy, it is your job to make our teams today. I want you to decide which 2 go to Diane's and which 3 go to Town Hall."
Chrissy-"I'm going to send..... Deanna, Mitchell, and..... Kristen to the house, and Benjamin and Harrison to Town Hall."
Gary-"Very well, go get ready guys. I'll see you all when you get back."
-
Deanna, Mitchell, and Kristen were in their van heading to Diane's house. Everyone was silent.
Mitchell-"I caught their alliance red handed. Harrison and I have our own alliance and we both want to make it to the end and claim the reward so I played a power move during the last Killer's Game round. If we can avoid the next Killer's Game, I think we can make it all the way."
The van pulled up to Diane's house. The 3 investigators stepped out and checked the scene outside. It was eerie.they had just spoken the other day, just like with Georgina, and now both are gone. All 3 of them thought to themselves the same thing, 'Who's next?'.
They walked around to the back door of the house and were instantly greeted by Robbin Evans and her camera crew. They were filming for Robbin's website news article, 'Robbin's Scoop'.
Robbin-"Once again, another grizzly murder has happened in the town of Sunrise Ridge. I'm here at the home of latest murder victim, Diane Pearlman, a beautician in the town. It was here within the last 12 hours that Miss Pearlman was killed in her own home by the mysterious killer that has been stalking the city the last few days. Diane's death is now the fourth death in the city, following Georgina Seeger and, of course, Matthew and Ashley Bundy. Questions have been raised as to who or whom have been behind the murders in this town. For example; Could the Mayor still harbor resentment toward Matthew for pointing out his crooked ways in the Mayoral election? What about the teacher that aided him? Could she lose more from this? What about the ex husband? Could he have been angered at her possibly dating or moving on from his abusive ways?"
Man-"EXCUSE ME!?"
Deanna, Mitchell, and Kristen whipped around on cue to see a visibly upset, and obviously extremely angry, Brad Stokely. No one heard his truck pull up, nor hear him walk up to the house. The red flannel on his shirt was nothing compared to the red in his face, with his stubbled grey hair acting as the smoke to the fire.
Brad quickly approached the reporter and her camera crew. Robbin's eyes bigger than saucers. Mitchell thought quickly and placed himself between Brad and the news crew.
Brad-"WHAT DID YOU SAY, YOU LITTLE BLONDE BIMBO?!"
Robbin-"I'm in the middle of filming a segment, sir."
Brad-"ABOUT MY WIFE! DON'T YOU EVER TALK ABOUT ME OR MY WIFE!"
Robbin-"Please calm down or I will have you arrested for disturbing the peace."
Brad-"YOU WANT DISTURBING THE PEACE, I'LL GIVE YOU DISTURBING THE PEACE!"
At this moment, Brad broke free of Mitchell's grip easier than breaking a popsicle stick with a sledgehammer. He walked up to Robbin and her camera crew with Mitchell still trying to keep him back. It was no use. Brad seemed to have the strength of 10 men. He reached the camera crew and grabbed the camera off of the tripod.
Brad-"HERE'S YOUR DISTURBING THE PEACE!"
With that, Brad delivered a pro wrestling style body slam to the camera. The camera hit the ground in an epic thud, shattering into a million pieces in the back driveway. The 3 members of Robbin's camera crew confronted Brad, but they haven't heard of his legend of bar fights.
Brad put one in a head lock and was about to punch him when another tried to stop him. They grabbed his free arm, but like something out of a movie, Brad spun the other cameraman around and placed him in a headlock as well. As the third member tried to pry everyone apart, he was met with a head butt square to the face. They went down with a bloody and possibly broken nose. He then pulled both of the other crew members together and both men met head first into one another and fell down as well. Now 3 men were down and one very angry and bitter man stood above the rest.
He looked over at Robbin and approached her. Mitchell tried his best to keep the peace, but after watching Brad win a 3 on 1 fight, he knew to keep his distance.
Brad-"I BETTER NEVER HEAR YOU MENTION ME OR MY WIFE EVER AGAIN! I WON'T HIT A WOMAN, BUT I CERTAINLY WILL HIT A BITCH!"
With that, Brad walked down the driveway, back into his truck, and sped off.
Kristen-"Jesus Christmas, are you guys ok?"
-
Benjamin and Harrison arrived at Town Hall. Neither said a word to the other as soon as the van left Headquarters. They got out and started walking up the steps to the building.
Benjamin-"So, you really heard of the girls and Doug having an alliance?"
Harrison-"Yeah, its the only reason I sent him out. I figure why work together like that when you're gonna have to turn against each other at some point. Let's say you and them are the last 4 and you're the Lead Investigator. They have no choice but to vote for each other. Why do that and then ruin your own chances of coming back and winning?"
Benjamin-"You put a huge target on your back. You know that, too?"
Harrison-"I knew what I was getting myself into when I sent Doug out. I've gone out already. If I have to go out again, I'm ready."
Benjamin-"Harrison is an idiot. You have a 50-50 chance of coming back from a Killer's Game. If the girls get their way, Harrison most likely won't come back. That's a plus for me at least."
Harrison-"I'm not gonna tell Benjamin or anyone that Mitchell and I are also working together. If I did, we'd both be out by now. Mitchell and I made a deal when Benjamin became Lead Investigator to have one of us walk out the winner, and we are sticking to that."
The 2 men walked into the Town Hall and were greeted by the desk clerk. An older lady by the name of Julia McMahon sat at the desk and welcomed the 2 men in as she did for Mitchell and Deanna just days before.
Julia-"Good morning, gentlemen. How can I help you today?"
Benjamin-"We're here for the murder investigation. We would like to go through the town records."
Julia-"That shouldn't be a problem. Town records are kept behind that door to the right."
Benjamin-"Thank you very much."
The 2 men walked through the door and found filling cabinets galore of information about the townspeople. They looked at each cabinet and followed the alphabet layout that was on each one.
Harrison-"Aa through Ag.... let's move down and skip this one."
The 2 men walked down and found the J's cabinets.
Harrison-"Bingo! Let's see what we can find."
He opened up a drawer and pulled out a file.
Harrison-"Jubaré. Nope, too far down."
Benjamin opened another cabinet drawer.
Benjamin-"Jonas. Getting closer."
They checked farther into the drawer and found Johnson.
Harrison-"Alright, let's see...... Allen, Amanda.... skip a few.... Stacy, Taylor, Thomas... Tracey. Got it!"
Benjamin-"Open it up."
-
Carl Levy-"I think my nose is broken."
The camera man struggled to his feet and grabbed a handkerchief from his back pocket. He put it against his nose to soak up the blood and let out a small yelp of pain. The other 2 members, Kevin Austin and Gregory Sanders, were still on the ground. Kevin was knocked out cold, while Gregory was dazed and probably concussed.
Robbin-"That man is a piece of crap! He needs to be locked up!"
Robbin then took out her phone and placed a call.
Robbin-"Yes, hi. My name is Robbin Evans and.... Yes, the reporter. I'm at the Pearlman house doing a story.... 19 Lane St.... Yes, I need an ambulance...... No, we did not find Miss Pearlman, I have 3 crew members that have been assaulted...... 1 has a possible broken nose, 1 has a possible concussion and the other is still unconscious..... Yes, he is breathing and... Oh, wait.... he just came too but he's still out of it obviously..... Yes....... Ok, thank you very much. Bye bye."
Michell-"Ambulance on their way?"
Robbin-"Yes, they'll be here shortly."
Almost, as if on cue, a siren was heard far off in the distance. Mitchell, Kristen, and Deanna tended to the 3 men as well as they could until 3 separate ambulances showed up. Each man was taken away and treated by each set of paramedics. As Carl willingly stepped into his ambulance, Kevin and Gregory had to be placed on the stretchers and placed in their own ambulance. All 3 men then left the area by way of their respective rides and brought to the hospital. Robbin stayed behind and loaded the camera's remains and boom stick into the news van.
Kristen-"Are you OK?"
Robbin-"Oh yeah. I'm used to it. In news, even if you're slightly off with a story, people will rip your head off."
Kristen-"Hey, if you don't mind me asking, how did you know about Diane's death?"
Robbin-"I have a police scanner."
Kristen-"What?"
Robbin-"I have a police scanner. It's basically a radio that is connected to the channels the police use. I left it on last night by mistake and woke up to hearing Officer Faye ask for a call to be traced."
Kristen-"OK. Thanks Robbin. I'm gonna get back to my group. Have a good day."
Robbin-"Thanks, you too."
Robbin loaded the last of the equipment and drove off from the crime scene. Kristen rejoined Mitchell and Deanna who were also just finishing up helping the paramedics load the 3 injured crew members into the ambulances.
Kristen-"How are they?"
Deanna-"Well, they reset that one guy's nose, hope I never see that again, and the other 2 they said most likely have concussions but will get checked out."
Kristen-"That's good. I talked to Robbin. She said she heard about Diane's death from her police scanner."
Deanna-"Well, all we gotta do is check the crime scene."
Deanna started walking to the door with Mitchell and Kristen closely following behind as they approached the back door.
Deanna-"Well, we know how they got in here."
She pointed to the broken window on the back door. Deanna then opened it and the 3 stepped inside.
-
Harrison-"Johnson, Tracey Kendall. Born 4/18/1980, died 7/22/2007. Cause of death was multiple injuries after a hit and run."
Lady-"Are you talking about that poor girl that died in town years ago?"
The 2 men whipped around and saw the desk clerk, Julia McMahon, walking in to check on them. They looked at her and both realized that they just might have a break in the case.
Benjamin-"Yes we are, ma'am. Did you happen to know her at all?"
Julia-"Well, I do not know her personally, but I did know about the court case."
Benjamin-"Court case?"
Julia-"Well, you see, she was found dead in front of Stokely Works. The poor girl was hit and left for dead. That same night, the man whose body hasn't been found yet, Matthew Bundy, was arrested for a DWI and they pinned him as the one who ran her over. He was placed on trial but acquitted because there was no evidence and no witnesses came forward."
Harrison-"Damn. Do you think he did do it?"
Julia-"I've heard of the rumors of him and some other guy's drunken antics."
Harrison-"Brad Stokely. We've seen him drunk. It's not pretty."
Julia-"I can only imagine. All I've heard is the stories."
Benjamin-"You have been a tremendous help. Thank you so much. Have a good day."
Julia-"Not a problem at all. You boys have a good day as well."
Harrison-"Actually, before we leave, could you make a copy of Tracey's papers for us, please?"
Julia-"I think I can arrange that. Give me one moment."
She took the paperwork from the 2 of them and walked out the door to find the copy room. Harrison and Benjamin headed back out the door to the lobby and waited for her to return.
-
As soon as the stepped in, Deanna heard a crunch under her feet.
Deanna-"Obviously she couldn't clean up the glass in time."
Kristen-"Wait, do you hear that?"
They then walked through the house and into the kitchen, where the faint buzzing sound was heard. It didn't take long to find the answer. The phone was still off the hook, lying right next to a puddle of blood.
Mitchell-"Hand me the swabs and some gloves, please."
Kristen took out a pair of rubber gloves and a cotton swab from their investigation kit and handed them to Mitchell. She the. Grabbed a second pair of gloves and the fingerprint kit and started working on the back door handle. Deanna got on her hands and knees and looked around on the ground.
Deanna-"We found the bullet casing last time at Georgina's house. Hopefully, if we can find the same type again this time, we might be able to confirm that it's some type of firearm as the murder weapon."
Mitchell bent down and looked at the blood and used his swab to collect a sample, placed it in a baggie. He just started to stand back up when Deanna yelled at him.
Deanna-"Freeze Mitchell!"
Mitchell stopped in what only looked like a awkward yoga position, trying so hard not to fall into the blood on the floor or stand and get in Deanna's way. She swooped in and grabbed something off the floor quickly so Mitchell could stand up fully.
Mitchell-"What was that about?"
Deanna-"You almost stepped on this."
She held up the bullet casing that she was able to spot fairly easily. Mitchell nodded to her as she placed it into a ziplock baggie. Kristen returned with the fingerprint kit with an upset look on her face.
Kristen-"No prints on the door. How about you guys?"
Deanna-"Nothing except the blood and the casing we found."
Kristen-"Should we call it here?"
Mitchell-"I think it's safe to say we can go."
The group packed their things and headed out the back door. Mitchell made sure it was locked again before they walked out to the front of the house and into the awaiting van.
-
Benjamin-"You know, her telling us about Brad being the one who killed her, that just pieced the Killer Clue from last night."
Harrison-"That's right. Maybe Brad is the Killer."
Benjamin-"Maybe we can pin him for it before the day ends."
Just then, the desk clerk, Julia, walked back in with the Mayor.
Daniel-"All I'm saying is if I have to keep hearing about this election, I might just kill someone myself."
Julia-"Shhh!"
She pointed over at Harrison and Benjamin, who acted like they couldn't hear them.
Daniel-"I mean I never would. It's frustrating. I've been cleared several times and then the murders started happening. It's a lot of stress in such a small time."
Julia-"I understand sir, but please don't lose your mind over it."
Daniel stepped into the elevator and headed back up to his office as Julia returned to Harrison and Benjamin with the freshly printed paperwork on Tracey Johnson.
Julia-"Here you are boys. Is their anything else I can do for you?"
Benjamin-"Well, if you don't mind, can you explain what Mayor McGee was about?"
Julia-"Oh, that. It was nothing much. He got yet another accusation of fixing the election."
Harrison-"How many times have they looked at it and cleared him?"
Julia-"Roughly 4 or 5 times. Hell, the guy that he ran against tried getting people to back off after the write in vote. He went on to better things and has no grudge against anyone here, so I don't know why people are still saying he was robbed."
Harrison-"Politics are weird thing. Anyway, thank you very much for all your help."
Julia-"You're very welcome. Have a good day."
Benjamin-"You too, thank you."
Harrison-"Thank you. Have a good one."
The 2 men walked out of Town Hall and headed back to the waiting van.
-
Both groups arrived back at HQ with their gathered information. Gary and Chrissy sat quietly while looking over their notes, waiting for the groups to enter the Briefing Room. Deanna, Kristen, and Mitchell walked in, and were soon followed by Harrison and Benjamin. Gary stood in his usual spot at his table and wait until everyone was situated at their desks.
Gary-"Alright guys, let's see what you got today. Track 1?"
Mitchell-"We gathered a blood sample to confirm it is Diane's and Deanna found a bullet casing like at Georgina's house."
Gary took the bullet casing from Mitchell and then went to retrieve the other one in the evidence locker. He looked at them immediately realized what he had.
Gary-"These casing are both the same. So what you do think about that?"
Deanna-"The Killer used the same weapon at both locations."
Gary-"Bingo! Now if we could get the weapon itself, we'd be in business. Did you find anything else?"
Kristen-"Yes we did. When we arrived to Diane's house, we found Robbin in the backyard doing a news piece on the murders. She made comments about the Mayor and Jennifer Harris possibly being the Killer. Then she mentioned Brad's name, and out of nowhere, he walks into the yard. He yelled at Robbin, smashed a camera, and beat down her 3 crew members before leaving."
Mitchell-"I tried to hold him back, but I saw the fight at The Hot Spot. I didn't wanna be apart of that."
Gary-"Well, you guys seemed to have a rough morning. Good job though out there today. Track 2, what did you get?"
Benjamin-"We got Tracey's record. It shows she died about 11 years ago. That was really all it said beside it saying she was killed in a hit and run, but then the desk clerk at Town Hall over heard us talking about it and told us what she knew. She said that she was found dead outside of Brad's business of a hit and run and that Matthew was also pulled over that night for a DWI. they linked the 2 together and wanted to charge him with her death. The court couldn't find any hard evidence to place him there when she died, and their were no witnesses, so they had to let him go."
Harrison-"It isn't much, but we also overheard the Mayor complaining about the election again. He said he was accused again, and since you brought up Robbin saying it in her story, I wouldn't be surprised if it was her."
Gary-"Nicely done guys. I believe that we've covered a lot of ground today. Go eat and get some rest. I'll see you guys laters."
Before anyone could move from their seats, the doorbell rang. The entire group looked at each other in confusion as to who would be at the door. Gary stepped out, which prompted everyone to get up and follow him out the Briefing Room and down the stairs to the door. To everyone's surprise, it was Walter DuChamps. He was holding a box, and still acting his usual nervous self.
Walter-"H-h-hello sir. I have this p-p-package for you."
Gary-"Thank you, Walter. Can you come in for a second?"
Walter-"Oh, um.. err... Y-y-yes, just for a m-m-minute."
Walter stepped in as Gary opened the package."
Gary-"So, how's work going at the post office?"
Walter-"The u-u-usual. I get l-l-letters, send them to o-o-others."
Gary looked in the box and his face turned pale like a ghost. He looked at Walter and his pale face turned red.
Gary-"Walter, is this some kind of joke?"
Walter-"W-w-what?"
Gary pulled out the contents of the box. A noose with a red and black envelope tied to it. Walter looked as if he borrowed Gary's pale face and started wearing it as his own.
Gary-"This is the second time we've gotten these from you. What's going on?"
Walter-"S-s-sgt. Fredo, I s-s-swear to you. I w-w-was left this a-a-as well."
Walter grabbed a brown letter from his duffle bag and handed it to Gary. He unfolded it and was met with the traditional label maker words.
"DELIVER TO SUNRISE RIDGE SHIPPING OFFICE AT 4:00 PM SHARP"
Gary-"Who dropped this off?"
Walter-"T-t-that's the thing. I n-n-never saw anyone."
Gary-"Walter, you know this looks bad for you, right?"
Walter-"I k-k-know sir. But h-h-honestly, I'm being s-s-set up. I s-s-swear."
Gary-"Listen, go home, relax, and take it easy. It's been a stressful day with the second death here in the city. I didn't mean to snap at you."
Walter-"It's ok. I'm u-u-use to it by n-n-now."
Gary-"Ok, have a good night Walter."
Walter-"Y-y-you as w-w-well."
Walter shuffled out the door and straight to his mail truck. The mail carrier looked terrified as he took off. However, was it all just an act to get sympathy, or was it genuine? Gary watched the mail truck leave and turned around to see the remaining 6 investigators looking at the envelopes still clutched in his left hand. He sighed as he addressed the group.
Gary-"It looks like we'll be playing the Killer's Game very soon. Until then, eat and get some rest. If you need me, you have my number. I'll see you guys later."
The group bid goodbye to Gary and he left. Kristen then stepped into the kitchen and went to the fridge to get a dinner started. She grabbed the door and paused.
Kristen-"Last time I open this, those freaking envelopes were in here. Does anyone else wanna do this?"
***
Deanna-"We have a good chunk of the puzzle started. I just hope we could get the rest before another Killer's Game. I really don't wanna go out again."
At 8:00 AM, the group woke up to the traditional breakfast drop off from Spencer and Tiffany. They walked down and saw Tiffany and Spencer standing in the kitchen.
Tiffany-"Hey Guys!"
The group gave her a yawning hello as they started grabbing coffee, trying to get themselves to the level of perkiness that she was already at.
Spencer-"Listen, we wanted to stay around and talk for a quick second about the case."
Chrissy-"You guys know we really can't talk about the case like that."
Spencer-"Well I think you'd like to right now. I was at The Hot Spot last night watching the Bruins game with Tyrone."
Harrison-"Go B's!"
Spencer-"You're a Bruins fan, too?"
Harrison-"I love that Dirty Water!"
At that moment, with both Harrison and Spencer wide eyed, they belted out "Dirty Water" by The Standells. While the majority of the investigators were amused, Benjamin was not. With rolling eyes, he shook his head back and forth. He then interrupted the impromptu concert.
Benjamin-"So, yeah, you were watching a hockey game. What else?"
Spencer-"Oh, yes, sorry. Anyway, we were watching the game and Tyrone was telling me that Brad's usually drinking night was tomorrow. We chatted during the intermission and he said he was getting a couple extra beers and making sure he's got an extra bouncer ready for his arrival."
Benjamin-"He's not banned?"
Spencer-"Tyrone's got a soft spot for everyone. He's kicked people out but allows them back in."
Kristen-"But why?"
Tiffany-"Small town. Business is business. You lose one customer, you start losing more. You lose Brad at a bar, you should basically shut down. He's probably spent more money drinking then on anything else."
Harrison-"Do you know what time he'll be there?"
Spencer-"Usually he's down there at about 5. Grabs a burger with onion rings and fries and knocks an entire pitcher of beer back before you know it."
Chrissy-"Alright, well thank you for the info guys. We're gonna probably chat with him tonight before he gets too drunk."
Tiffany-"Not a problem, guys. Take care."
Spencer-"Bye guys."
The group said goodbye to the diner workers and they headed out and back to The Shaw Shack. The 6 remaining investigators made their plates and ate in the lounge together.
Chrissy-"Harrison sent out Doug the other night and now our coalition is down a member. Looking at him gets me more and more ticked off every second. I don't know who put it in his head, but both of them are gonna be gone soon."
Harrison-"I know I'm a target because of what happened the other night. I know I'm going out tonight, regardless of the vote. I just hope I pick the correct map."
The group filed into the Briefing Room after finishing their breakfast and waiting on Gary's arrival. It wasn't a long wait, as Gary walked in the door by the time they all took their seats. Gary was surprised by the readiness of the group today.
Gary-"Wow, I was not expecting you all to be in here and ready for the day. I'm very impressed."
Chrissy-"Gary, before you continue, we got a tip on a suspect today. Spencer and Tiffany told us that Brad Stokely was gonna be at The Hot Spot tonight for his usual drinking night around 5. We were hoping to question him about Diane and what we learned from our tracks yesterday."
Gary-"You guys came in today with all cylinders firing. Great idea, we'll do that. Track 1, I'm going to send you to The Hot Spot tonight. I figure we'll send you at 4:45 just to make sure you get time in case Brad gets there early. Try to talk to him, Tyrone, or any other suspects you might see. Track 2, I got a call on my way in from Rachel Neary, the blood test results are in from Diane's house. She said we can pick it up at any time. Go over and get the results and try and get any and all information you can from her. You are all doing a great job, I'm very proud of you. Go get ready for the day. You're dismissed."
-
At 4:40 PM, Mitchell, Deanna, and Kristen arrived at The Hot Spot. They stepped in and were greeted by Tyrone, who called them over to his station of the bar.
Tyrone-"Hey guys, what are you doing here? Haven't seen you since the benefit."
Deanna-"We were told that Brad would be coming by here tonight. Has he been in yet?"
Tyrone-"No, not yet. What's going on with the case?"
Kristen-"Its been tough, but it's going good."
Deanna-"Well, good for some, a nightmare for others."
Deanna-"Kristen didn't have the 'privilege' of going out on a Killer Game yet. I can clearly understand why she thinks everything is all sunshine and cupcakes. Meanwhile, Harrison, Benjamin and I have returned from a Game and know it's not fun. With her and Chrissy getting busted, I think the 2 of them need to experience a night out soon."
Mitchell-"Well, while we're waiting for Brad, can we get a little info about you and some sodas please?"
Tyrone-"Not a problem. Cola OK?"
Deanna-"That's good for me."
Kristen-"Yep. That's perfect."
Tyrone-"Give me a minute and I'll get them for you."
-
Benjamin and Harrison arrived at Rachel's office. Benjamin was ticked off upon his arrival.
Benjamin-"I don't know how many times I've seen this lady now and she won't tell us a thing. If I go on another Track involving Rachel, then I think I'll be the next Killer in this damn town."
The 2 men walked into the office and waited for Rachel to enter as well. When she did, she immediately rushed to grab the file and hand it over when she saw Benjamin.
Rachel-"I can confirm the blood at the scene is a match to Miss Pearlman's DNA. Unfortunately, without her body I can't do any other test to completely confirm that. That's all I have for you gentleman. Have a good day."
She went to leave as quickly as she had walked in, but Benjamin blocked her way. He had anger written on his face, while Harrison looked terrified that he was about to become the referee in a fight between the two of them.
Benjamin-"Listen, lady, I'm tired of you ducking us every time we have to talk to you. We need to know where you were the night of the murders, and we want them now."
Rachel-"I am not comfortable telling you, and with that attitude I refuse to answer any questions you have."
Benjamin's face started getting red. He looks like he was gonna pop.
Benjamin-"Every single time I see you, you tuck tail and run like you are hiding something, and I don't care how crappy your excuse is. Every other person we've talked to gave us an alibi or some stupid story except you. So if you don't wanna come clean yet, then I'll have no choice but to call up the police and have you arrested right NOW!"
Harrison got in the middle of Benjamin and Rachel as fast as he could. He knew this was gonna turn almost violent the way Benjamin started shouting. Rachel, to her credit, would not go down without her own fight.
Rachel-"YOU NEED TO GET OUT OF MY OFFICE NOW, OR I WILL CALL THE POLICE ON YOU!"
Harrison-"Please, guys, please calm down. We can all talk rationally. We're all grown adults."
Benjamin-"HOW HARD IS IT TO TELL US WHERE YOU WHERE THAT NIGHT!?"
Rachel-"I KNOW MY RIGHTS AND YOU ARE INVADING THEM RIGHT NOW!"
Benjamin-"DON'T WANNA TALK AGAIN! WHAT A SURPRISE!"
Harrison-"BENJAMIN, CHILL OUT AND SHUT UP!"
Harrison was able to get the two of them quiet, although Rachel was nearly in tears. He looked back at her and saw the pain in her face.
Harrison-"Rachel, I'm sorry. Please, we don't wanna cause any problems. We're stressed, everyone in town is stressed. I completely understand that you are uncomfortable telling us your story, but we need to know where you where. Please."
Rachel could see the sincerity in Harrison's face. She wiped away her tears and took a deep breath.
Rachel-"Ok, fine. I was on a date."
Harrison-"Thank you, Rachel. Does it happen to be someone in town?"
Rachel-"No..... I don't think you will know her."
Harrison was just about to say something but stopped.
Benjamin-"I'm sorry..... Her?"
-
Tyrone arrived with the drinks for the group and pulled up a stool to sit with the group.
Tyrone-"So, what's up?"
Mitchell-"We just wanna know about you before Brad shows up. We never got a chance to talk the last time we were here."
Tyrone-"That's no problem. I lived here for about 14 years then moved to Trenton, New Jersey for roughly 18 years. My parents stayed back there but I moved back up here and opened The Hot Spot about a year after coming back. Anything else?"
Deanna-"Did you ever have a girlfriend?"
Kristen-"Girl, are you looking?"
The four of the started laughing at what had been said, but Tyrone was quick to bring the conversation back on track.
Tyrone-"Well I did, actually I had a few. Had one here before I left originally, a few in New Jersey, and when I came back I tried to find my first girlfriend here but I never found her. Couldn't find her on FaceBook or anywhere. Found out she died a couple of years back."
Mitchell-"If you don't mind me asking, do you know how she died?"
Tyrone-"I ran into her parents, they were shocked about how big I got. I asked about her, and they unfortunately told me that she developed cancer and passed away. This was roughly...... About 10 years ago."
The investigators looked at each other, knowing that Tracy Johnson died 10 years prior as well. Could Tyrone be lying about his girlfriends death? Their next question was cut short by one of Tyrone's bouncers, Trevor Barker.
Trevor-"Hey, sorry guys, but Tyrone, heads up. Brad just pulled up."
Tyrone-"Thanks, Trevor. Make sure Danny has the door covered and then stand by the bar in case things get outta hand."
Trevor-"You got it. Be right back."
Tyrone turned back to the group.
Tyrone-"Sorry, guys. Gotta get back at it."
Kristen-"We completely understand. We're gonna hang back until Brad gets settled so we can talk to him."
Tyrone left and took his place behind the bar. His bouncer, Trevor, positioned himself just off to the side. Brad then walked in and took a seat right in front on Tyrone.
Brad-"Hey Tyrone. Can I get a burger and fries and a pint?"
Tyrone-"Coming right up Brad."
Brad then placed his head down on the counter and stayed like that, as if he already had a few.
-
Harrison-"Am I confused? Did you say 'her'?"
Rachel was still out of it with tears still in her eyes, but she knew exactly what she was saying.
Rachel-"Yes. I did say 'her', and her name is Sasha."
Benjamin-"So, wait.... You're.... Gay?"
Tears instantly filled Rachel's eyes.
Rachel-"Yes I am."
She started crying at that moment. Benjamin and Harrison looked at one another with the same puzzled look on their faces.
Harrison-"Why couldn't you just say that to begin with?"
Somehow, through the sobs, Rachel was able to talk to the two men.
Rachel-"You don't know how hard it is. I grew up in a strict Catholic family. When I told them I thought I was gay, they tried sending me to away to a gay conversion therapist. I refused, so when I turned 18 they kicked me out. Then you have people like Matthew Bundy who tried to make me into a monster, which obviously I'm not. I've been trapped ever since because I'm terrified on how people will treat me. Then you came in asking about Tracy, and...."
She broke down again, sobbing harder than before.
Rachel-"Just trust me, you won't understand."
As she turned away, a hand pulled her back around and embraced her in a tight hug.
Harrison-"One of my best friends is gay."
Rachel cried into his shoulder as he held her tight, in his way telling her she wasn't alone, no matter what she thought. However, it was quickly broken up by Benjamin, who stepped in. He just looked blankly at Rachel and Harrison. Then, all of a sudden, he grabbed both of them and pulled them into a hug as well.
Benjamin-"My younger brother is gay."
Rachel and Harrison looked at Benjamin during the hug and realized, for once, Benjamin wasn't being a jerk and was actually sincere.
Benjamin-" My brother, Jacob, came out to me originally when we were in high school. I was the first person he came out to and I've been by his side ever since. When Rachel said she was gay and we wouldn't understand, I immediately thought of Jacob and his fights and his struggles."
-
Tyrone returned with a tall beer and a burger and fries for Brad. He set down a bottle of ketchup and mustard next to it. He then had to nudge Brad to get him to pick his head up.
Tyrone-"Hey, Mr. Stokely, your food and beer are ready."
Brad-"Thanks, Tyrone. Put it on my tab."
Tyrone-"Way ahead of you, Mr. Stokely. Just need your card."
Brad-"You're a good man, Tyrone. Don't change."
Brad handed Tyrone his debit card and he walked away to fill another order, while Deanna, Mitchell and Kristen all looked at each other like they were in an alternate reality. They were not being deceived; Brad actually complemented someone.
Kristen-"I think this is as best a time to talk to him. When he's still sober and throwing out complements."
Mitchell-"Good idea."
The 3 of them walked over to Brad, who took a few bites out of his burger and fries.
Mitchell-"Hey, can we talk?"
Brad-"You guys again? Well, I guess. What the hell do you want?"
Mitchell-"First off, we are so sorry about your wife's death. We wanna know why you are so upset even though you divorced."
Brad took a long, refreshing sip of his beer to wash down some more of his burger. He set the glass down and wiped his mouth.
Brad-"That women was a damn saint for putting up with a bastard like me. I never deserved her."
Kristen-"Is that why you cheated on her? Because you felt that way?"
Brad-"What? I'd never cheat on her. Who the hell would tell you that?"
Kristen-"Diane told some other investigators that when they came to talk to you a few days ago."
Brad-"She's still covering for me. God bless that women."
Deanna-"I'm sorry?"
He took a deep breath, then took another gulp of his beer. He looked up with tears in his eyes, which was extremely weird for him.
Brad-"About 12 years ago, some girl got ran down in front of my business."
Deanna-"Tracey Johnson."
Brad-"I guess, I don't remember her name, but I was in the office at that time. I was having an argument with some punk kid that screwed up my accounting numbers. All of a sudden, I see Bundy's truck fly by. About 10 minutes later, they walked out fired, and then someone starts yelling that they need an ambulance. Matthew really did run that lady down."
Mitchell-"I'm sorry, but I'm confused. How did Matthew not get arrested for it?"
Brad-"I refused to testify because Matthew and I go back and I owed him a favor. Diane begged me to step forward. She pleaded with me, but I told her I just couldn't. Matthew and I were good friends. Hell, you could say he was like a brother to me. I couldn't watch him go down like that. She completely understood, but she was pissed at me for it. We had arguments for months and then we got divorced and I drank more and more afterward."
Deanna-"Good damn. Are you serious?"
Brad-"Yes, and I should of said something. If I did, I know Diane and I would still be together. Hell, she'd still be alive."
With that, Brad placed his head back down on the counter, right between his empty plate and nearly empty beer glass. He took a deep breath and picked his head back up.
Brad-"I messed up. I ruined the chance for that family to get justice, I ruined my marriage, and I ruined several lives."
He finished off his beer and gestured for another one. All of a sudden, a group of men walked into the bar. Brad looked over and recognized them immediately. He looked back at the investigators.
Brad-"You guys might wanna go. This isn't gonna be pretty."
-
Harrison-"Benjamin, are you serious?"
Benjamin-"Yes. My little brother, Jacob. He came out to me while him and I were in high school and I've had his back ever since. I won't let anyone mess with him and I've kicked a lot of ass in the past 20 years since he came out."
Harrison-"I just can't believe it. He yelled at this lady for days to give up information and to find out she's gay and he can relate to it.... There are no words. It's just a surreal moment that they can connect and she could open up to this."
Benjamin-"So, you were on a date the night of the murders?"
Rachel wiped away her tears and took a deep breath.
Rachel-"Yes. I met Sasha at a coffee shop. We talked for a little bit and we decided to go out together. She knew this little place just outside of town called The Rise, which is a gay bar. I got out of working a double shift here, went home and got ready, and she drove us there. We had a few drinks, we went back to my place, and.... Well, you get the idea."
Harrison-"So you two are an item now?"
Rachel-"I don't know. I wanna be, but I don't know if this is me."
Benjamin-"And who says it's not what you're supposed to be?"
Rachel-"My parents, gay conversion therapists, my family's church."
Benjamin-"Alright, alright, alright, here's the thing though; who's life is it?"
Rachel-"It's my life."
Benjamin-"There you go. Just because they don't agree with it does not mean you need to change your life to make others happy about their lives. Whatever in life makes you happy is what you need to worry about. If you like girls, then like girls. You like hospitals, you got a job in one."
Rachel-"I just wish there was that 1 day I could take back."
Harrison-"What day was that?"
-
A group of 3 men walked into the bar and noticed Brad. They approached him as he drank his second beer in record time.
Gus-"Hey, Dave and William, look who we found. Hey old man, where's your buddy now? You wanna start a fight 3 on 1 now?"
Brad-"Listen, I'm not starting anything tonight. I wanna sit here, watch the Red Sox, and eat my food."
Dave-"What, can't win a fight on your own?"
Brad-"I'm not fighting tonight. I told you that. I'm watching the game and eating my food. That's all."
William-"I bet that your wife could put up a better fight."
Brad had the thousand yard stare. He was almost tunnel vision like when the guy said that. Brad slowly turned in his seat and stood up, getting right in the face of the guy who said that.
Brad-"You listen to me, you little punk. You don't ever mention my wife. That women is an angel and if you ever say anything about my Diane again, you'll be saying it from the floor. You hear me?"
William-"Diane? The lady who died?"
Brad-"Yes. She is a saint, and.."
Gus-"And you are the guy that killed her probably."
Brad stepped aside from William and right into Gus' face?
Brad-"You wanna say that again?"
Cold and quietly, Gus leaned up to Brad's face.
Gus-"Your bitch wife is dead because you're a disgusting drunk."
Brad stepped back. He looked at the 3 men, then to the investigators. They knew exactly what was about to happen after the other day with Robbin's camera crew. Brad then made a gesture to Tyrone, which quickly got his attention.
Tyrone-"What's up Mr. Stokely?"
Brad-"You still have my tab open?"
Tyrone-"Yes sir. Got you card right here."
Brad-"Hold onto it. I'm gonna knock some punk's teeth out and I'll need you to add what is broken onto my tab."
Before anyone could say anything else, Brad grabbed Gus by the arm, quickly spun himself, and judo flipped him over and onto the ground. Dave ran forward to attack Brad from behind, and was quickly met with an elbow to the face. William took a run at him, but Brad sidestepped him, grabbed the back of his pants, and threw him up and over the bar. Gus got back up and lunged at Brad, who quickly got him in a head lock and started to apply pressure. Dave got back to his feet, but got hit with what only could be described as a professional wrestling style thrust kick to the stomach. William threw a wild punch that caught Brad square on the side of the jaw. He looked like he was gonna fall down, but regained his senses, removed Gus from the headlock, and shoved him into William and then Brad proceeded to football style tackle the two men to the ground. Brad landed a few punches until Dave pulled him off of his friends, and they pushed and shoved each other back towards the door.
CRASH!!!!
Kristen-"Holy crap!"
Deanna-"Oh my, what just happened?"
Mitchell-"They just went through the glass door!
The 3 investigators rushed over to help the 2 bouncers. When they got to the door, they see Brad standing up and stretching out his shoulder after landing hard on the pavement. Tyrone came running out to see what had happen as well. He was in shock when he walked outside and realized that the door was still closed.
Tyrone-"OH MY GOD! WHAT THE HELL!?"
Brad reached into his wallet and pulled out his business card and handed it to Tyrone.
Brad-"I'm sorry about this, Tyrone. Get a list of what I broke and what their bodies broke and come by tomorrow. It's on me. Just bring my debit card as well."
With that, Brad walked away under his own power to his pick up and left. The three men had to be helped to their feet. Tyrone just stood their, card in hand, still as a statue and still in shock at what had just happened.
Kristen-"You OK Tyrone?"
Tyrone-"He's...... He's...... He's not human. How?"
Danny-"Hey, boss man, this guy is cut bad."
They look over to the three men and William was seen to have a large gash from the glass door on his arm. The bouncers got to him and Trevor pulled his cell phone out and called an ambulance for him. Deanna walked over to help, but caught sight of her watch.
Deanna-"Guys, it almost 7:00. We need to get back to HQ."
Mitchell-"You're right. Hey, Tyrone!"
Tyrone whipped around and saw Mitchell walking up to him.
Mitchell-"Listen, obviously we know there's an issue here right now, but we need to leave. Hang on."
Mitchell took a sharpie out of his pocket and took the business card from Tyrone, wrote the HQ's number on the blank backside, and handed it back to the still stunned Tyrone.
Mitchell-"That's the number to our Headquarters. If anything happens, call us immediately."
Tyrone-"Well, thanks, but I already know where you guys are set up. It doesn't matter though, I'll let you know if anything happens. Have a good night."
Mitchell-"You too. Bye."
Mitchell then rushed off to the van, where Kristen and Deanna were already waiting. He hopped in and they left for HQ.
-
Rachel-"Well, it started about 14 years ago. After I first started working here, I was seeing someone. I thought we were in love. Then a year and a half later, I found out she was cheating on me. I was so hurt that she could do that. A few months later, I find out she was engaged, and then...."
She started breaking down in front of Benjamin and Harrison. She tried to compose herself as well as she could, but it was apparent that it wasn't going to work at all.
Rachel-"I was working here one night.... They bring in a lady that got ran over..... It.... It was her."
She broke down completely in tears, almost falling to her knees.
Rachel-"I..... I.... Couldn't believe it....."
Benjamin and Harrison picked her back up and held her tight as she sobbed into their shoulders.
Rachel-"I loved Tracey..... How could that happen?"
Benjamin and Harrison both looked at each other as Rachel continued to cry. They both had the exact same thing in mind; is the Tracey she mentioned the same Tracey from their case? Their was only one way to find out. Harrison nodded at Benjamin and started to speak.
Harrison-"Rachel, is Tracey's last name Johnson?"
Rachel couldn't speak through her sobs, but she shook her head with her answer of yes. Harrison and Benjamin held her close and she finally started to calm down enough to speak. Benjamin walked away to the water cooler in the corner of the room and got a cup of water for her. Rachel sipped it and got herself calm.
Rachel-"I cried over her for what felt like hours that day. People asked me why I was crying so bad that day. I'm so scared of coming out to others, I told them it was my cousin that died."
Harrison-"But you've come out now to us. I mean, the circumstances surrounding you saying you're gay could of been better, but you're out now."
Benjamin-"Listen, I'm sorry I've given you such a hard time earlier. If I knew what I know now, everything would have been different. And I hate to say it, but we have to leave."
Rachel-"Its OK, and thank you for helping me open up. You guys take care."
The men said goodbye, but first gave Rachel one last hug. They then left the office and made their way back to the van.
-
The group's made their way back to HQ and filed into the Briefing Room. Gary was already standing at his table, going over notes with Chrissy. She left for her seat and Gary addressed the group.
Gary-"Alright, I'm hoping we covered some more ground today. Track 1, what did you get out of Brad?"
Deanna-"Well, before we talked to Brad, we chatted with Tyrone about his life. He lived here and then moved to New Jersey for a while then came back. He said he tried to reconnect with an old girlfriend when he got back, but found out from her parents that she passed away from cancer about 10 years ago."
Gary-"Well, that puts us at around the same time frame that Tracey died. Their could be more that Tyrone isn't telling us. Now what about Brad?"
Mitchell-"It was bizarre. He was all well behaved. We chatted about his wife and he said she was a saint for putting up with him. When we asked about his cheating, he denied it and told us that she was covering for him because he witnessed Matthew hit Tracey with his truck. Matthew and him were friends and he didn't wanna see his friend get locked away so he refused to testify, which is why Bundy got off scott free. Diane and Brad argued, fought, and he started drinking more and they ended up divorcing because of it."