It's pretty sad that a player who only lasted 3 rooms gets all the votes.

In this case though, Annie was a really good player. f she lasted longer, I am sure she would've been just as fast and successful.
And rewatching the War Fan run again, I felt that Elise was way too slow as a second runner. I do feel sorry for her team for all the time they lost in the Tomb o the Headless Kings, she still took her sweet old time as a second runner. I don't think they would've won even if the production error never occurred. It would've been a failed escape.