Most Memorable Legends Episode Elimination Thread

[Purple Parrots Fan]

Someone didn't include Applewood Amulet on the countdown list, and included Secret Map twice. It's fixed now.

Anyways, the #4 spot goes to The Lost Hornpipe of the Pirate Captain. Aside from the solid temple run and the "a musical thing that does a jig" answer, there are more exciting episode than this. Also, the remaining three runs have been put together since there are few runs remaining at this point.

#4: The Lost Hornpipe of the Pirate Captain
#5: The Mussel Shell Armor of Apanuggpak
#6: The Applewood Amulet of Emiliano Zapata
#7: John Sutter and the Map to the Lost Gold Mine
#8: The Levitating Dog Leash of Nostradamus
#9: The Secret Map of the Bandit Queen
#10: The Lucky Medallion of Atocha
#11: Lawrence of Arabia's Headdress
#12: Henry VIII's Great Seal
#13: The Discarded Seal of Ivan the Terrible
#14: The Golden Earring of Henry Morgan
#15: The Ruby Earring of Benzibab
#16: The Much-Heralded Helmet of Sir Gawain
#17: The Dragon Lady and the Blue Pearl
#18: The Jeweled Scabbard of Sforza
#19: The Mask of Shaka Zulu
#20: The Milk Bucket of Freydís
#21: The Golden Pepperoni of Catherine de Medici
#22: The Good-Luck Watch of Empress Eugenie
#23: The Priceless Portrait of the Polynesian Girl
#24: Robin Hood and Marian's Ladder
#25: The Snakeskin Boots of Billy the Kid

1x03 - Galileo's Cannonball
2x16 - The Lucky Pillow of Annie Taylor
3x40 - The Jewel-Encrusted Egg of Catherine the Great

[PurpleParrot319]

Galileo's Cannonball is only memorable for the first ever temple win. I don't remember anything else that happened in this episode, so it gets 3rd place.


#3: Galileo's Cannonball
#4: The Lost Hornpipe of the Pirate Captain
#5: The Mussel Shell Armor of Apanuggpak
#6: The Applewood Amulet of Emiliano Zapata
#7: John Sutter and the Map to the Lost Gold Mine
#8: The Levitating Dog Leash of Nostradamus
#9: The Secret Map of the Bandit Queen
#10: The Lucky Medallion of Atocha
#11: Lawrence of Arabia's Headdress
#12: Henry VIII's Great Seal
#13: The Discarded Seal of Ivan the Terrible
#14: The Golden Earring of Henry Morgan
#15: The Ruby Earring of Benzibab
#16: The Much-Heralded Helmet of Sir Gawain
#17: The Dragon Lady and the Blue Pearl
#18: The Jeweled Scabbard of Sforza
#19: The Mask of Shaka Zulu
#20: The Milk Bucket of Freydís
#21: The Golden Pepperoni of Catherine de Medici
#22: The Good-Luck Watch of Empress Eugenie
#23: The Priceless Portrait of the Polynesian Girl
#24: Robin Hood and Marian's Ladder
#25: The Snakeskin Boots of Billy the Kid


2x16 - The Lucky Pillow of Annie Taylor
3x40 - The Jewel-Encrusted Egg of Catherine the Great

[The Red Jaguars]

You don't remember that episode either for one of the dumbest Legends in the history of the show? 

Since we have two episodes left now, we will vote on which one we think is the best.

Anyways, I vote "The Lucky Pillow of Annie Taylor" as the most memorable episode in Legends. Its one of the few episodes I remember from start to finish and never get tired of watching. From the amazing comeback in the final temple game, Missy's stellar performance during the temple run, and the amazing finish at the end where Missy is hugging everyone, it was truly a great episode.

Don't get me wrong, Catherine the Great is one of my all time favorite episodes also. I loved the way they ended the show with creative camera work and a very exciting team. I just find Annie Taylor slightly more fun to watch. 

2x16 - The Lucky Pillow of Annie Taylor: 1
3x40 - The Jewel-Encrusted Egg of Catherine the Great: 0

#3: Galileo's Cannonball
#4: The Lost Hornpipe of the Pirate Captain
#5: The Mussel Shell Armor of Apanuggpak
#6: The Applewood Amulet of Emiliano Zapata
#7: John Sutter and the Map to the Lost Gold Mine
#8: The Levitating Dog Leash of Nostradamus
#9: The Secret Map of the Bandit Queen
#10: The Lucky Medallion of Atocha
#11: Lawrence of Arabia's Headdress
#12: Henry VIII's Great Seal
#13: The Discarded Seal of Ivan the Terrible
#14: The Golden Earring of Henry Morgan
#15: The Ruby Earring of Benzibab
#16: The Much-Heralded Helmet of Sir Gawain
#17: The Dragon Lady and the Blue Pearl
#18: The Jeweled Scabbard of Sforza
#19: The Mask of Shaka Zulu
#20: The Milk Bucket of Freydís
#21: The Golden Pepperoni of Catherine de Medici
#22: The Good-Luck Watch of Empress Eugenie
#23: The Priceless Portrait of the Polynesian Girl
#24: Robin Hood and Marian's Ladder
#25: The Snakeskin Boots of Billy the Kid

[Purple Parrots Fan]

Plus, Lucky Pillow is memorable for the infamous boob grab at the tiebreaker. Anyways, this is seriously hard. I mean, they BOTH deserve to be #1 in my opinion. As for my vote though, it will go to The Lucky Pillow of Annie Taylor. I vote for that episode for the same reasons TRJ stated. The Jewel Encrusted Egg of Catherine the Great is memorable too, since it was the final episode. But Lucky Pillow is a tad more memorable than Jewel Encrusted Egg in my opinion.

2x16 - The Lucky Pillow of Annie Taylor: 1
3x40 - The Jewel-Encrusted Egg of Catherine the Great: 0

[PurpleParrot319]

I'm going to give Lucky Pillow its third vote. Catherine the Great was a great episode too, but Lucky Pillow deserves this one.

2x16 - The Lucky Pillow of Annie Taylor: 3
3x40 - The Jewel-Encrusted Egg of Catherine the Great: 0

NOTE: I gave Lucky Pillow the point PPF forgot to give it.

[The Red Jaguars]

And it looks like our winner is Annie Taylor! 

#1: The Lucky Pillow of Annie Taylor
#2: The Jeweled-Encrusted Egg of Catherine the Great
#3: Galileo's Cannonball
#4: The Lost Hornpipe of the Pirate Captain
#5: The Mussel Shell Armor of Apanuggpak
#6: The Applewood Amulet of Emiliano Zapata
#7: John Sutter and the Map to the Lost Gold Mine
#8: The Levitating Dog Leash of Nostradamus
#9: The Secret Map of the Bandit Queen
#10: The Lucky Medallion of Atocha
#11: Lawrence of Arabia's Headdress
#12: Henry VIII's Great Seal
#13: The Discarded Seal of Ivan the Terrible
#14: The Golden Earring of Henry Morgan
#15: The Ruby Earring of Benzibab
#16: The Much-Heralded Helmet of Sir Gawain
#17: The Dragon Lady and the Blue Pearl
#18: The Jeweled Scabbard of Sforza
#19: The Mask of Shaka Zulu
#20: The Milk Bucket of Freydís
#21: The Golden Pepperoni of Catherine de Medici
#22: The Good-Luck Watch of Empress Eugenie
#23: The Priceless Portrait of the Polynesian Girl
#24: Robin Hood and Marian's Ladder
#25: The Snakeskin Boots of Billy the Kid

[Purple Parrots Fan]

And what a great choice for winner it is. But really, both the Top 2 episodes were #1 worthy.

[The Red Jaguars]

Hell, I love Galileo's Cannonball and wouldn't have mind if that one won either. 

[Purple Parrots Fan]

I guess I'm the only person who's gonna do these higher/lower rankings:

#1: The Lucky Pillow of Annie Taylor (Fine)
#2: The Jeweled-Encrusted Egg of Catherine the Great (Fine)
#3: Galileo's Cannonball (A little lower)
#4: The Lost Hornpipe of the Pirate Captain (A little lower)
#5: The Mussel Shell Armor of Apanuggpak (Fine)
#6: The Applewood Amulet of Emiliano Zapata (Higher)
#7: John Sutter and the Map to the Lost Gold Mine (Fine)
#8: The Levitating Dog Leash of Nostradamus (A Little higher)
#9: The Secret Map of the Bandit Queen (A little higher)
#10: The Lucky Medallion of Atocha (Fine)
#11: Lawrence of Arabia's Headdress (Fine)
#12: Henry VIII's Great Seal (A little higher)
#13: The Discarded Seal of Ivan the Terrible (Fine)
#14: The Golden Earring of Henry Morgan (Fine)
#15: The Ruby Earring of Benzibab (Lower)
#16: The Much-Heralded Helmet of Sir Gawain (Fine)
#17: The Dragon Lady and the Blue Pearl (Fine)
#18: The Jeweled Scabbard of Sforza (Higher)
#19: The Mask of Shaka Zulu (A little higher)
#20: The Milk Bucket of Freydís (Fine)
#21: The Golden Pepperoni of Catherine de Medici (Lower)
#22: The Good-Luck Watch of Empress Eugenie (Fine)
#23: The Priceless Portrait of the Polynesian Girl (A little higher)
#24: Robin Hood and Marian's Ladder (Higher)
#25: The Snakeskin Boots of Billy the Kid (As much as this pains me.... probably not in my Top 25)