Legends Episode Ranking System - COMPLETE

[The Red Jaguars]

Now that I am out of school, I am going to try and find a better site to post these reviews and update them with. Thanks for fixing the Mata Hari one too, I can't believe I forgot about that one.

[Purple Parrots Fan]

So you're not gonna use the wordpress site I take it? Not that I object, I never really liked that anyways. Don't take it the wrong way, the site looked nice. But I'm just not big on wordpress. I hope you're still up for the photo gallery idea too. I'm sure you can fit that on whatever site you use. I mean, it's gonna be a whole separate site after all. I'm not trying to pressure you or anything, I just thought I'd ask. I'd help out more with the site making process, but I'm not good at making sites.

[The Red Jaguars]

I am not very good at making sites myself. It takes a little bit of work to get what I want. If this was back during the Nick GaS days, it would probably be much easier for me. And by the way, I like your photo gallery idea too. I am sure that it will be easy to find a way to incorporate it to the site once it is up. You just have to get the pictures for episodes like Golden Cricket Cage, Snow Cone, Bifocal Monocle, and Cracked Crown.  

[Purple Parrots Fan]

Plus, you made that "Room of the Golden Idols" site back in the Nick Gas days. And that looked pretty nice, even though you stopped updating it eventually. I really have no experience with making sites, but I can imagine it's a lot of work getting everything all configured and set up. And once you get the main site set up, we can add the photo gallery along with it too.

And my screencapping Bifocal Monocle and Cricket Cage? No thank you. But I do have really bad episodes like John Henry and Dried Apple Half screencapped. So that sort of makes up for it.

[Purple Parrots Fan]

Here's another set of stats that I found to be interesting. Who covered the most of what filming day. The following is a list of who dominated which production day of episodes the most. All written down by me on paper. And yes this can be added to the OP.

Season 1, Layout 1:
Blackbeard: TRJ
Belshazzar: PPF
Galileo: TRJ
Dead Man's Hand: PPF
Total:
TRJ: 2
PPF: 2

Season 1, Layout 2:
Lost Hammer: TRJ
Golden Cricket Cage: TRJ
Golden Ship: TRJ
Map to the Lost Gold Mine: Both
Total:
TRJ: 3
Both: 1

Season 1, Layout 3:
Sultan Saladin: TRJ
Alhambra: TRJ
Genghis Khan: PPF
Trojan Horseshoe: TRJ
Kamehameha: TRJ
Total:
TRJ: 4
PPF: 1

Season 1, Layout 4:
Magellan: TRJ
Moccasins: PPF
Great Seal: PPF
Lucky Pig: TRJ
Total:
TRJ: 2
PPF: 2

Season 1, Layout 5:
Ponce de Leon: TRJ
Jean Lafitte: TRJ
Oracle Bowl: PPF
Leonardo Da Vinci: PPF
Total:
TRJ: 2
PPF: 2

Season 1, Layout 6:
Zenobia: TRJ
Buddha: TRJ
Shiva: TRJ
Stone Marker: TRJ
Joan of Arc: Both
Total:
TRJ: 4
Both: 1

Season 1, Layout 7:
Sir Edmund Hilary: TRJ
Shaka Zulu: Both
Atahualpa: TRJ
Silver Saddle Horn: TRJ
Gordian Knot: Both
Total:
TRJ: 3
Both: 2

Season 1, Layout 8:
Cobra Staff: TRJ
Blue Pearl: Both
Mata Hari: TRJ
Lost Lariat: PPF
        : Both
Total:
TRJ: 2
Both: 2
PPF: 1

Season 1, Layout 9:
Lawrence of Arabia: TRJ
Davy Crockett: Both
Snake Bracelet: TRJ
Anne Bonny: Both
Total:
TRJ: 2
Both: 2

Season 1 Total:
TRJ: 24
PPF: 8
Both: 8

This is just Season 1 so far. I really didn't cover a lot of Season 1 at all. And we didn't collaborate on a lot of episodes this season too. The most interesting to me is your almost total dominance on S1L3 and S1L6's filming day. And a handful of production days where we both ranked two episodes on the same day. Other than that, this season was all you. I'll update the rest of this list later, but this is what I got so far. And I copied and pasted this list from the "production day rankings" chart, to use as a template. You can add this to the OP whenever you're ready. Thoughts?

[The Red Jaguars]

Great idea! I It will be interesting to see if one of us actually wrote a review for every production day. I can't believe I wrote 60% of the reviews from Season 1 either. This was definitely my least favorite season to review though because most of these episodes are boring and average. Of course, there are a few gems.

I have a pretty good memory, so I can help update the list too for Season 2. I wonder if there will be a production day where only one person wrote entirely for?

Season 2:

Season 2, Layout 1:
Silver Horseshoe: PPF
Secret Battle Plan: PPF
Golden Stallion: TRJ
Silver Cannonball: PPF
Total:
PPF: 3
TRJ: 1

Season 2, Layout 2.1:
Harriet Tubman: Both
Captain John Smith: TRJ
Dr. Livingstone: PPF
Blackfeet Chief: Both
Total:
Both: 2
PPF: 1
TRJ: 1

Season 2, Layout 2.2:
Mush Pot Hat: PPF
Cracked Crown: TRJ
Imperial Purple Robe: Both
Stone Head: PPF
Total:
TRJ: 2
PPF: 1
Both: 1

Season 2, Layout 2.3:
Atocha: TRJ
Emiliano Zapata: PPF
Benjamin Franklin: TRJ
Annie Taylor: PPF
Total:
TRJ: 2
PPF: 2

Season 2, Layout 3.1:
Missing Eye: Both
Enormous Iron Nose Ring: TRJ
Very Tall Turban: PPF
Scheherazade: PPF
Total:
PPF: 2
TRJ: 1
Both: 1

Season 2, Layout 3.2:
Sacred Ring: TRJ
Cosa Rara: PPF
Montezuma: TRJ
Lost Lion Tail: TRJ
Total:
TRJ: 3
PPF: 1

Season 2, Layout 3.3:
Efoua: TRJ
Iron Mask: TRJ
Queen Nzinga: Both
Two-Cornered Hat: TRJ
Total:
TRJ: 3
Both: 1

Season 2, Layout 4:
Silk Sash: Both
Golden Goblet: TRJ
Leopard Skin Cloak: TRJ
Snakeskin Boots: PPF
Total:
TRJ: 2
PPF: 1
Both: 1

7. Season 2, Layout 5.1:
Golden Pepperoni: PPF
Golden Earring: TRJ
Milk Bucket: PPF
Missing Weather Maps: TRJ
Total:
TRJ: 2
PPF: 2

Season 2, Layout 5.2:
Nostradamus: TRJ
Icarus: PPF
Dolley Madison: PPF
Polynesian Girl: Both
Total:
PPF: 2
TRJ: 1
Both: 1

Season 2 Total:
TRJ: 18
PPF: 15
Both: 7

I completed Season 2 using your format. I can't add it to your post though because I can't edit other people's content unfortunately. Hopefully everything is accurate though. This season is more balanced though when it comes to reviews completed. We both almost wrote an equal amount of reviews. We also did very little collaborations this season too. This was definitely the most fun season to review.

[Purple Parrots Fan]

Actually, I like the idea of keeping all three seasons worth of stats separated. It would certainly save space in my above post, so it doesn't get too stretched out. And yeah, Season 2 was much more equal with who wrote which episode. Still not a lot of collaboration ones this season, but I'm pretty sure Season 3 will definitely have more. I also agree that Season 2 was definitely the most fun to review. They had some great episodes, and it's also my favorite season of the show. So without further ado, here's the Season 3 stats.

Season 3.1:
Bifocal Monocle: TRJ
William the Conqueror: Both
War Fan: TRJ
Sir Gawain: PPF
Total:
TRJ: 2
PPF: 1
Both: 1

Season 3.2:
Lion-Headed Bracelet: PPF
Lion-Slashed Jacket: Both
Secret Map: TRJ
Thornwood Gavel: TRJ
Total:
TRJ: 2
PPF: 1
Both: 1

Season 3.3:
Snow Cone: TRJ
Upside-Down Compass: PPF
Bent Shaving Pan: TRJ
Marble Armrest: TRJ
Total:
TRJ: 3
PPF: 1

Season 3.4:
Smashed Printing Plate: TRJ
Imperial Wizard: TRJ
Useless Map: Both
Robert the Bruce: Both
Total:
TRJ: 2
Both: 2

Season 3.5:
Discarded Seal: PPF
Mysterious Manuscript: PPF
Dried Apple Half: Both
Missing Portrait: PPF
Total:
PPF: 3
Both: 1

Season 3.6:
Roland: TRJ
Queen Boadicea: Both
Pirate Captain: PPF
Mi Linh: TRJ
Total:
TRJ: 2
PPF: 1
Both: 1

Season 3.7:
Red Sash: TRJ
Poseidon: TRJ
Lily-Crested Crown: PPF
Apanuugpak: TRJ
Total:
TRJ: 3
PPF: 1

Season 3.8:
Metal Beard: PPF
Mummified Hand: TRJ
Lost Taj Mahal Turban: TRJ
Melted Head: PPF
Total:
TRJ: 2
PPF: 2

Season 3.9:
Gwalior: PPF
Belle Boyd: TRJ
Pytheas: Both
Sojourner Truth: Both
Total:
Both: 2
TRJ: 1
PPF: 1

Season 3.10:
Sforza: PPF
Empress Eugenie: TRJ
Benzibab: TRJ
Catherine the Great: TRJ
Total:
TRJ: 3
PPF: 1

Season 3 Totals:
TRJ: 20
PPF: 12
Both: 8

This season was a little less equal, where half the reviews came from you. But, I still contributed quite a bit, much better than Season 1. The collaboration number is still low, but to be fair, we didn't start that until the project was almost over. Still kind of wish we would've done it sooner, since those reviews were my favorite. Our grand total of collaboration reviews was 23, where the numbers should go 8, 7, 8 for Seasons 1, 2, and 3 respectively. When I wrote this down on paper, I got 7 collaborations for Season 2, while you have 5 down. Maybe I wrote something down wrong? Either way, you can now add these stats to the OP. Which I'm pretty sure you can fit, even with three separate posts.

[Red Jaguars Fan]

Maybe I should give my contributions to this if I can. I need something to keep my interest in Legends going.

[The Red Jaguars]

I do miss doing these reviews because it was nice to go back and watch some of these episodes I have not watched in a long time. I will admit that I even enjoyed doing reviews for episodes like Stone Marker or Mystical Spellbook even though they weren't the most exciting or memorable episodes. I want to come up with another type of reviewing system, but I don't what quite for. I might even rank some of the episodes PPF already covered to see what kind of score that I come up with.

[Purple Parrots Fan]

I do miss doing these reviews because it was nice to go back and watch some of these episodes I have not watched in a long time. I will admit that I even enjoyed doing reviews for episodes like Stone Marker or Mystical Spellbook even though they weren't the most exciting or memorable episodes. I want to come up with another type of reviewing system, but I don't what quite for. I might even rank some of the episodes PPF already covered to see what kind of score that I come up with.

If you do that, then I'm gonna rank your episodes. I hope you're okay with this.

[The Red Jaguars]

Yeah, there are a few episodes I wanted to review to see what score I came up with. I am not sure how we are going to rank them in the original post though. Maybe average the two scores together? Here are the episodes I want to try that you reviewed:

- Lost Lariat
- Oracle Bowl
- Cracked Crown
- Dr. Livingstone
- Hans Holbein
- Sir Gawain

[Purple Parrots Fan]

I didn't review Cracked Crown. You did.

[Purple Parrots Fan]

Oh, and the above "Production days ranked by author" posts have been added to the OP. If the links section looks too cluttery, you can remove it.

[Purple Parrots Fan]

Triple post. But I just want to say this regarding the "episode rewrites," and I wanted to run it by you first.

Maybe we can rewrite these episodes in collaboration format. Like, the episode reviews can look like this:

MOAT: #/10:

Description goes here.

Credit goes to *blank* here

MOAT: #/10: (Second persons score)

Description goes here.

So instead of completely writing a new episode from scratch, we can just add on to an already published episode review. And at the end, we can average in both scores total. I hope this makes sense. What do you think?

[The Red Jaguars]

I think I have an idea what you are talking about, but I want to make sure I am on the same wavelength as you.

Let's say I write my review for Oracle Bowl. Would it look like this?

Moat: #/10 (Your Score)
Moat: #/10 (My Score)

Legend: #/10 (Your Score)
Legend: #/10 (My Score)

...

Final Verdict (Your Score)
Final Verdict (My Score)

Is that what you are talking about? If so, then that is a marvelous idea! I would even use your pictures if I am using your review. It would be less time spending to find pictures for episodes I don't have saved.